MINISTER for the Economy and Transport Ieuan Wyn Jones and our business columnist Dylan Jones-Evans have clashed over the SME credentials of WAG’s new business support strategy.
Last week the minister outlined a new direction of business support, which will see the £100m Single Investment Fund being replaced by a repayable loan approach.
The strategy also sees a greater focus on infrastructure including potentially funding to the tune of £200m the provision of high-speed broadband – at 100 megabits per second in urban areas – for companies in Wales by 2016.
The strategy is an acceptance that WAG can no longer pretend it can be a wealth creator through direct business support intervention, but instead needs to focus on providing an environment which will give businesses the best chance to flourish.
However, writing in his column in the Western Mail on Saturday Prof Jones-Evans, who is director of the Wales Fast Growth 50 initiative, claimed the new direction has been designed at the expense of the indigenous SME sector.
Prof Jones-Evan said: “It is hard to disagree with one of the central planks of the Economic Renewal Programme, namely of moving away from a grant culture towards one that is based on repayable loans.
“However, as 50% of the current grant money (ie the £100m Single Investment Fund) is now being transferred to infrastructure projects, this means that the small business sector in Wales is losing out on £50m of repayable loan capital.
“At a time when bank lending to small firms remains weak, it would seem WAG has reduced the amount of finance available to support the growth of the SME sector in Wales, the poorest region in the UK, where access to capital remains weaker than in other regions.
“One also has to question the focus of the remaining business support fund on six sectors of the economy, where the other £50m of investment cash will be targeted.
“From my experience of running the Wales Fast Growth 50 project for the past 12 years, growth is not limited to any particular sector, but can occur in any company which has the right product or service, an excellent management team and, more importantly, access to funds and markets to make it happen.”
He added: “If anyone had bothered to ask the thousands of small businesses in Wales for their views on business support, I am sure they would have said that it is not business support per se that is wrong, but the bureaucratic and time consuming processes.”
Prof Jones-Evans’ views produced a swift response from Mr Jones in a letter published in the Western Mail published yesteday.
He wrote: “It seems Dylan Jones-Evans must have not read the details of our new policy ‘Economic Renewal: a New Direction.
“From now on we will focus our resources on targeting the systemic issues within the Welsh economy and SMEs are at the heart of this new approach. We will be investing in infrastruc
Read more…